Elections Optional: How the Supreme Court Made Voting a Privilege

by Rob C.

Art by Pat Bagley

TL;DR:

The Right has finally done it — they’ve made voting in America optional. Not for themselves, of course, but for everyone else. The Supreme Court — that robed extension of the Federalist Society — has decided that protecting the right to vote is just too much work. What used to be a right is now a privilege, one you’ll have to earn by navigating voter ID laws, gerrymandered districts, and whatever new hoops they dream up next.

Please Like & Follow if you believe democracy should still mean something.

Subscribe now

⚖️ Judicial Review or Judicial Coup?

The conservative movement has been trying to gut the Voting Rights Act longer than Donald Trump’s been lying about crowd sizes. For decades, they’ve framed racial gerrymandering protections as “unfair advantages,” as if Black voters getting representation somehow violates the natural order of things.

The Supreme Court once stood as a defender of democracy — or at least pretended to. But those days are gone. Today’s Court, led by Chief Justice John Roberts, is steadily dismantling the Voting Rights Act piece by piece, while claiming they’re just “restoring balance.”

Roberts, who once wrote that “things have changed in the South,” clearly meant for the worse. His decades-long crusade against the Voting Rights Act reads like a Heritage Foundation wish list. The same law that ensured Black Americans could actually vote without being terrorized is now treated like an annoying relic — a historical souvenir from a time when democracy briefly flirted with equality.

And speaking of the Heritage Foundation — let’s not forget this is the same think tank that produced Project 2025, the fascist playbook for dismantling democracy and selling off the federal government like a clearance sale at Mar-a-Lago.¹

🏛️ Democracy Pending: Please Hold.

You’d think when people vote and win, that’d be the end of it. Democracy, right? Wrong. In today’s America, a Republican loss just means the counting was “rigged,” or the districts were “unfair,” or (God forbid) people of color actually voted.

Look no further than House Speaker Mike Johnson — a man so devoted to “family values” that he’s protecting the pedophiles in Epstein’s black book by refusing to seat a duly elected Democrat from Arizona. Why? Because that new representative’s vote could force a discharge petition to release those very files. Better to leave voters unrepresented than risk exposing the rot.

Meanwhile, red states are racing to see who can suppress the most votes the fastest. Texas and Georgia are tightening ID laws. Florida is arresting people for the crime of voting while poor or confused. And North Carolina — oh, bless their hearts — managed to draw maps so racially biased that even the ghost of Strom Thurmond blushed.

🗳️ The Roberts Court: Making Disenfranchisement Great Again

The current case before the Court — whether states can consider race when drawing districts — is the latest nail in democracy’s coffin. It’s being sold as “colorblindness,” but what it really means is powerblindness. The Court is telling Black voters, Latino voters, and urban voters: you exist, but politically, you don’t count.

This isn’t an accident. It’s a decades-long project — from Goldwater’s “states’ rights” dog whistle to Reagan’s “welfare queens,” straight through to Trump’s “stop the steal.” The throughline has always been the same: fewer voters = more power for the few.

They’ve just moved from subtle racism to open authoritarianism. When Roberts and friends gut the Voting Rights Act again, they’ll smile and tell you it’s about “federal overreach.” Translation: Elections are fine — as long as they don’t work.

💰 Freedom for Some, Silence for the Rest

The American Right loves to talk about “freedom,” but their version of freedom is a gated community. You’re free to vote — if you can afford the ID, the time off work, the gas to get to the polls, and the luck to live in a district that hasn’t been carved into a jigsaw puzzle.

The Supreme Court’s majority, soaked in billionaire money and evangelical zeal, isn’t just ignoring democracy — they’re rebranding it. Voting is no longer a right; it’s a privilege of property. They’re putting the “For Sale” sign on your ballot box.

And while they do, they’ll tell you it’s all to “restore faith in elections.” Sure — just like the arsonist restoring faith in fire safety.

🚨 A Warning

The path from “voting restrictions” to “elections optional” is the path from democracy to dictatorship. Once people can no longer vote the powerful out, those in power no longer have to pretend to care.

The GOP’s assault on voting rights isn’t a bug — it’s the system working exactly as designed and The Supreme Court is now their instrument.

They’ll say it’s just a ruling. Just one law. Just one more ID requirement. But make no mistake — they’re not just redrawing districts. They’re redrawing the boundaries of freedom itself.

They can’t win hearts, so they change the rules.
They can’t win votes, so they throw them out.
They can’t win fairly, so they redefine “fair.”

Because when the right to vote becomes a privilege, the people are no longer citizens. They’re subjects.

¹ See Democracy for Sale by Robert Cain — for a deeper look into how think tanks like Heritage, billionaires like the Kochs, and politicians like Trump have worked in lockstep to strip democracy for parts.

© Robert Cain
✊ Subscribe, share, and remember — democracy only works if we fight for it.